Peanut butter cup 

Eating peanut butter out of ones ass

U want a peanut butter cup

Peanut butter cup by anonymous October 12, 2019

Nutter Butter 

The uncomfortable sensation of having one of your testicles slide up the ol poop shoot.

Dude I just had a Nutter butter experience for the first time!

Nutter Butter by pinkieb October 21, 2019

shrek butter 

A peanut butter alternative made from pistachios.

Bro slap some shrek butter on me appy slices, im allergic to peanuts dawg

shrek butter by timburtonswillywonka January 18, 2020

Smurf butter 

A smurf melted on bread

I ate smurf butter

Smurf butter by Wyatts mom February 28, 2020

Pumpkin butter 

When preforming vaginal and anal sex, the shit when preforming anal sex gets schmeared and or stuck to the penis or foreign object. Pumpkin butter is formed when after fucked in vagina and anal cavity and brown white substance that forms is called pumpkin butter.

Me and Sara had a lot of sex last night, she's a freak and did anal. There was a lot of pumpkin butter.

Pumpkin butter by Dr.PimpDaddy March 2, 2020

Alabama butter churn

The sexual act of rubbing butter in a female partner's genitals (preferably one of your cousins or sisters), having her urinate it back into your mouth, then regurgitating it back into her anus and using it as anal lubricant

"Hey dude last night I did an Alabama butter churn with my sis"
"This is why we don't talk anymore you sick fuck"

Alabama butter churn by NotNath April 15, 2021

Poo butter 

Poo Butter is the nasty gelatinous fluid that forms under the folds of a fat ladies titties on an extremely hot day. The sweat runs down and collects in the dark cooler folds of skin and congeals into a texture similar to cooled bacon grease thereby becoming poo butter.

Mabel, make sure you lift up both titties and wash all the poo butter out from underneath them

Poo butter by Nauticamike May 15, 2021