Definitions by Dr.PimpDaddy

Pumpkin butter 

When preforming vaginal and anal sex, the shit when preforming anal sex gets schmeared and or stuck to the penis or foreign object. Pumpkin butter is formed when after fucked in vagina and anal cavity and brown white substance that forms is called pumpkin butter.

Me and Sara had a lot of sex last night, she's a freak and did anal. There was a lot of pumpkin butter.

Pumpkin butter by Dr.PimpDaddy March 2, 2020