Peanut butter cream pie

When a man ejaculates into another persons (male or female) butt then that person deficates leaving a semen covered pile of feces.

After I came in her ass she dropped a peanut butter cream pie right on my bed!

by ThePaDave October 7, 2006

Pineapple Cream Pie Shake

When a gay guy gets pounded, He opens the flood gates of hell and shit coming out with it and into a cup for their partner to drink

Damn babe, that was an amazing pineapple cream pie shake.

by PineappleCreamPie April 15, 2021

Cream pie for the straight guy

When you finish inside your female partner than slide down and lick it out of her

I dropped a load in her and she asked for a cream pie for the straight guy and pushed my face between her thighs.

by Teknodruid June 7, 2017

Anal Cream Pie Surprise

When you are fucking a girl doggy style right before you pull out and cum in her face, you stick your dick in her ass and then you cum inside her anal canal.

"Me" Dude I gave Sam an Anal Cream Pie Surprise last night, it was amazing!
"Friend" Dude that's gross!

by Su1c1dal Duck December 11, 2013

gulf shores cream pie

When you eat a girl out after you dumped your load inside of her.

Dude, I gave that girl a gulf shores cream pie.

by cornbread5000 April 19, 2014

Banana Cream Pie

When having anal sex, you slap them in the face, cum in their ear and mix it with the wax hence creating banana cream pie. then you take a dump in their mouth, forcing them to eat the before mentioned "banana cream pie"

That banana cream pie left me dazed for weeks.

by Jackson March 30, 2005

ruffled pumpkin cream pie

When you’re having sexual intercourse with a basic white girl sporting Ugg’s in august and she is deepthroating a pumpkin spice latte and as she cums she screams “hobby lobby!”

I was with heather the other night..givin her the ol ruffled pumpkin cream pie…and when it was over she called her mom and then tweeted about it..basic

by Saineone711 September 17, 2021