Top definition
When you are fucking a girl doggy style right before you pull out and cum in her face, you stick your dick in her ass and then you cum inside her anal canal.
"Me" Dude I gave Sam an Anal Cream Pie Surprise last night, it was amazing!
"Friend" Dude that's gross!
by Su1c1dal Duck December 11, 2013
Get the mug
Get a Anal Cream Pie Surprise mug for your barber Manafort.