The act of sticking your finger in your ass and pulling it out to find cum and nutty filled shit on your fingers. Then proceeding to stick them in your partners mouth
My dad gave me a raging new york nutter butter last night. or my grandmothers new york nutter butter taste the best
by DonkeyMcPunch July 1, 2024
Get the New York Nutter Butter mug.gooey stuff that comes out of your pee pee that makes girls pregnant
it also tastes very good it has a nice texture like butter
it also tastes very good it has a nice texture like butter
by hawkseye November 28, 2018
Get the Nutter butter mug.The act of when a male covers his penis with peanut butter and then proedes to have sex and then cum in the male or female.
by mcsquigilnugets December 22, 2018
Get the Nutter Butter mug.by A gun to ma YEET May 6, 2021
Get the Nutter Butter mug.A person who is absolutely filthy at gaming, no one stands a chance against a nutter butter. A nutter butter will ALWAYS dump a shit on you
No skin: “Guy 240!, he just double pumped me!”
No skins friend: “damn dude that guys a nutter butter”
No skins friend: “damn dude that guys a nutter butter”
by Wtf1276 June 9, 2018
Get the Nutter Butter mug.When the male ejaculates during a prostate exam. When the male unintentionally busts a nut while at a doctors clinic getting a physical exam.
Bro! The last prostate exam I went to was crazy. As soon as the doctor was knuckles deep in my ass, I couldn't help but nutter butter. It was scary and exciting all at the same time.
by NewJerzJr March 13, 2024
Get the Nutter Butter mug.Guy 1: Dude are you ok?
Guy 2: Ohhh! My fucking NUTS!
Guy 1: That was a Nutter butter! You aint fucking anytime soon!
Guy 2: Fuck you!
Guy 2: Ohhh! My fucking NUTS!
Guy 1: That was a Nutter butter! You aint fucking anytime soon!
Guy 2: Fuck you!
by LuisMS November 2, 2023
Get the Nutter butter mug.