The idea that one's opponent in a debate is a butler who must provide all the proof, evidence, and sources one demands, regardless of relevance, burden of proof, or the reasonableness of the request. The butler fallacy treats the opponent as a servant obligated to serve whatever intellectual goods the demander wants, whenever they want them, in whatever form they specify. It's typically combined with moving the proofpost: each demand met with a new demand, each source rejected with a call for a different source. The goal is not to reach understanding but to establish dominance, to exhaust the opponent, to make debate so laborious that the opponent gives up. The butler fallacy is the signature move of bad-faith arguers who treat debate as a power game.
Example: "He treated her like a butler: 'Fetch me a source. No, not that one—a better one. No, not that one—a more recent one. No, not that one—a more authoritative one.' Butler fallacy in action: he'd appointed himself master and her servant, expected to be served endlessly, gave nothing in return."
by Dumu The Void March 10, 2026
Get the Butler Fallacy mug.The Bugger Ball is designed to catch and hold pesky biting insects that never seem to leave us alone!
by JR603 May 23, 2025
Get the Bugger Ball mug.Related Words
by wheresthegrass August 31, 2025
Get the Bullerish mug.A contemptuous or mocking term used to refer to bugs, insects, or other small pests. Often employed to express annoyance, frustration, or disdain toward them.
by soysmash September 15, 2025
Get the Bugger mug.When you interrupt an intimate moment between a cow and bull in a barn that results in bull seman showering your face
by funnyfarm September 26, 2025
Get the bullerized mug.by Jason Moran March 7, 2008
Get the muted bugle mug."did you see that guy dodge the defender? he's a slippery bugger!"
"you cant catch a dart frog. they're slippery buggers!"
"you cant catch a dart frog. they're slippery buggers!"
by maximushyrule June 25, 2009
Get the Slippery Bugger mug.