Butternutter 

Morning after a one night stand a dude puts his dick in butter and cums into it , uses the butter on toast and serves it with sprinkled birth control and feeds it to her. Gourmet

“Dude I totally have her the butternutter this morning”

Butternutter by theoneemochick March 3, 2021

Butternutter sniff 

Butternutter sniff, when you scratch your the asshole. Then drag it across your nuts and make someone smell your finger.

Last night I caught my girl with a butternutter sniff.

Butternutter sniff by Jacob Santos May 30, 2019

buttnutterdo 

The residual matter that expels from ones rectum after being sodimized with a buttered penis.

Rob: Hey Nate, what is dripping out of my ass?
Nate: Thats my buttnutterdo, bro! Goes great on toast.

buttnutterdo by Greekosyk March 19, 2019

Fluff my Butternutters 

When you want to curse but you are around children and you want to curse.

Linda screamed "FLUFF MY BUTTERNUTTERS!" In the daycare when she stubbed her toe on the table.

Fluff my Butternutters by Muffin6611 September 11, 2016

Butter Nutter

Having thick, yellow-ish, unhealthy jizz.

My boyfriend gave me a nasty facial last night and his jizz was all yellow and gross." "He's obviously a Butter Nutter.

Butter Nutter by CottonNuts123 March 23, 2011

Buttnutter 

When you put it in her but and don’t pull out in time to buy on her back

Hey bro did you smash last night ?
Yeah bro but I had to buttnutter
Damn, bruh

Buttnutter by Wenger January 12, 2018

Butter Nutter

Using butter for sexual lubricant

I ran out of ky jelly so I broke out the country crock. Nothing like a good butter nutter

Butter Nutter by Joshua Dark June 14, 2020