Perspectivist Demarcation Theory of Science

A model arguing that demarcation is always from a particular perspective (theoretical, cultural, historical). There is no perspective‑free way to distinguish science from pseudoscience. Different scientific communities, or even individuals, may legitimately draw boundaries differently based on their epistemic values. Perspectivist demarcation does not collapse into relativism; it insists that each perspective be transparent and justified. It highlights how claims of “pseudoscience” often serve to protect orthodox perspectives.

Perspectivist Demarcation Theory of Science Example: “Perspectivist demarcation theory showed that from a Popperian view, psychoanalysis is pseudoscientific, but from a pragmatist perspective, it offers clinical insights—both are valid demarcations relative to different goals.”

Perspectivist Demarcation Theory of Science by Dumu The Void April 28, 2026