Butter penis 

This means butter has a very small penis he cant become a daddy he gonna be a virgin for his whole life time.

Selva has a butter penis so he can't be my daddy.

Butter penis by IANxSALTY December 12, 2021

peanut butter and penis

when you stick your dick inside a Peanut butter and jelly sandwich and you have someone take a bite ;)

girl: hey dude, u wanna do peanut butter and penis with me
guy: sure!
*10 minutes later
guy:owww my godamn cock!

peanut butter and penis by mr badass 000 April 29, 2012

penix butter 

The sauce flying out of one or more penix

I blew my penix butter all over her face

penix butter by Godkiller March 5, 2010

penis butterballs 

When you’ve been working all day and your man bits are nice and marinated.

See also: duck butter, gooch grease, fromunda cheese

I’ve got penis butterballs; I need to shower so my girlfriend will suck my nuts.

penis butterballs by ThunderDome420 February 11, 2021

Penus butter

A fancy way of saying smegma

I’m going to make a penus butter and jelly sandwich

Penus butter by Crocotta1 April 18, 2026

Penisbutter 

1. Lube or lubricant

2. Jizz, semen, sperm,

1. Hey man can u get me some penisbutter, me & Sarah are gonna get it on!( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
2. OH YEAH Gimme that Penisbutter!!! OOH( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

Penisbutter by Fucking.Duck May 30, 2015

penisbutter 

one who likes the taste of cum.

May I offer you some penisbutter and jelly. I have some in my fuckstick.

penisbutter by AndyC October 23, 2003