Mud cream pie 

The after effects of shooting your load while engaging in anal sex

Tina got mud cream pie all over my sheets last night.

Mud cream pie by Mojojo1029 August 31, 2017

the cream pie 

When something is the best

Blank said to rkelly I just won 1 million dollars
Rkelly would say that’s the cream pie

the cream pie by Rkellyblang October 29, 2017

bavarian cream pie 

Finishing inside during anal sex.

"We were doing anal and I was asked not to finish inside. I couldn't help it, next thing you know she had a Bavarian cream pie!"

bavarian cream pie by Cheyenne_93 November 15, 2017

Chocolate cream pie 

A delicious pie with cream and chocolate. Nothing sexual just a delicious pie.

I ate a delicious chocolate cream pie. Chocolate cream pie is delicious

Chocolate cream pie by Top6Facts May 8, 2018

homemade cream pie

When you bust a nut and it shoots into your own butthole. Then, dribbles down and sits in the crevice next to your gooch and your nutsack.

Jim: Bro my girl said she was gonna cut me off from sex.
John: Bro what are you going to do?
Jim: I don’t know. Looks like I’ll be spending tonight trying to make a homemade cream pie.
John: Damn bro that sucks. Good luck with the homemade cream pie.

homemade cream pie by J. R. Granelli November 14, 2018

Chocolate Cream Pie 

When you throw chocolate chips at a girl’s vagina.

“My girlfriend got quite upset when I made a chocolate cream pie”

Chocolate Cream Pie by Dahlia A.N. March 9, 2019

Brown cream pie

Is when you make a girl cum While ur smashing her In her kitty and shitting on ur dick at the same time

Bro that hoe was nasty she gave me a brown cream pie

Brown cream pie by PapiJunglez April 20, 2020