The meta-view that our catalog of "logical fallacies" is itself a constructed system for policing thought within a specific rhetorical tradition (Western academic debate). What one culture condemns as an "appeal to emotion" might be another's preferred method of moral persuasion. The rulebook for "valid argument" is a constructed social agreement, not a holy text of pure reason.
Example: "In the courtroom, a lawyer's emotional story about a victim is powerful persuasion. In a formal debate, it's dismissed as an 'appeal to pity' fallacy. The Theory of Constructed Fallacies shows that the error isn't in the emotion, but in breaking the constructed rules of the specific reasoning game we're playing. The fallacy is a foul in one sport that's the main move in another."
by Abzu Land January 31, 2026
Get the Theory of Constructed Fallacies mug.