Nutter in the Butter

When you just straight up shove a Nutter Butter® candy bar right up your ass while you scream out "Give me the cream!" and cum all over the floor.

"Nutter" refers to you cumming, "in the Butter" refers to anal stimulation with a Nutter Butter®

Oh man, Chad, I had the BEST Nutter in the Butter last night. You gotta try a Nutter in the Butter. You will not believe the sensation.

by nutterinthebutter July 29, 2018

Butter Nutter

Using butter for sexual lubricant

I ran out of ky jelly so I broke out the country crock. Nothing like a good butter nutter

by Joshua Dark June 14, 2020

Plumper Butter Nutter

Taking the Jizz from a fat person and making a sandwich out of it.

This Plumper Butter Nutter Taste really good with Tuna !!

by Awesomeness02 March 3, 2015

Nutter Butter

When a girl shits on a man’s penis and he then precedes to bust a load into the girls booty

After Michael gave Allie a nutter butter, she went home to shower off the mixture of jizz and shit

by Sexpun November 14, 2019

Nutter butter

Nutter butter is when someone nuts and makes butter out of it to eat on toast/

Leo really likes to eat my nutter butter!

by Hollow112 June 19, 2024

New England Nutter Butter

The act of inserting heavy cream into ones anus and a man churning it with his penis until he ejaculates.

“Me and Chris made some New England Nutter Butter last night!”

by Theodore Foreskin July 5, 2025

Nutter butter

A nutter butter is almost like lube but made out of butter it is applied when you're about to have intercourse.

Wait let me apply some nutter butter.

by Kingsyrup February 17, 2022