A line from American Pie: The Wedding. It basically means "holy shit, I didn't expect this..."
Steve Stiffler: Well polish my nuts and serve me a milkshake!
by Lemon Duck February 20, 2009
Get the Well polish my nuts and serve me a milkshake mug.
A meaningless phrase originally coined by Derrick from RHPC
Can be inserted into nearly any conversation.
Person 1: Hey, were you at the party last night?

Person 2: Nah, I was off the 5 next to the Ikea. You know, near the McDonald's where we got that strawberry milkshake?
by mole_mole_mole February 25, 2020
Get the Off the 5 next to the Ikea. You know, near the McDonald's where we got that strawberry milkshake? mug.

Tijuana Milkshake

When a gay Mexican Nazi zombie nuts in your eye, leaving you with pink-eye.
Guy 1: "You know man, now that I'm finally out of prison I'm going to change my ways for the better. Maybe go back to college and become a doctor."

Guy 2: "Not with that pink eye your not, what happened Frank?"

Guy 1: "Oh don't worry, that's just a souvenier from my Tijuana Milkshake."
by Cocaine-cola December 14, 2018
Get the Tijuana Milkshake mug.

Bathtub Milkshake

When You Drink Bath Water (Intentionally or Unintentionally)
My Brother Had a Bathtub Milkshake Last Night
by PuppyDogs&Weezer March 23, 2023
Get the Bathtub Milkshake mug.

Carl's Milkshake

While your kid is sleeping, sneak into his room with your wife and start to bone down. If you can finish and yell "CARL" before he wakes up, you win.
We snuck into his room, started pounding it out, and I was like "CARRRRRL!" Then he woke up. It was awkward. And now I'm on a government list. But I got a Carl's Milkshake!
by Danosue June 07, 2020
Get the Carl's Milkshake mug.

cookies and cream milkshake

referring to the ejaculate of both a white and black man in a woman's mouth at the same time.
After giving stan and carlos both a blow job she had a cookies and cream milkshake.
by suburbanmommy January 29, 2012
Get the cookies and cream milkshake mug.