The result of an unsuccessful attempt to perform anal sex, whether male or female. The anus will be clean, reddish in color and concave from multiple attempts.
Brian told me he had a "dented starfish" thanks to Jacks relentless efforts on his 1st anal experience.
Ryan wants me so bad... He knows I'm a virgin back there but has problem giving me a "dented starfish" until it happens.
Ryan wants me so bad... He knows I'm a virgin back there but has problem giving me a "dented starfish" until it happens.
by Clifford "The Mayor" August 7, 2024

Guy 1: hey man have you ever put it in a girls butt?
Guy 2: Yeah, but I usually give her a wet starfish just to be a douche bag.
Guy 2: Yeah, but I usually give her a wet starfish just to be a douche bag.
by The real mike jones December 13, 2014

Nick - "What's up with that starfish? It's moving around strangely."
Justin - "That's a quivering starfish! Quick! Make a wish!"
Justin - "That's a quivering starfish! Quick! Make a wish!"
by brosephbryan December 26, 2015

by Horrorhead June 15, 2018

The male version of a Starfish Princess. Male sexual partner who remains 'unmoved' during lovemaking, physically non-responsive (like a starfish). They are basic in the bedroom, usually prefer cowgirl so they can just lay there or basic missionary. They also have a tendency to not last long in bed. They expect their partner to do all the work or just have no drive and just want to get it over as quick as possible.
Stacy took the Brad from the club after promising amazing sex only to be disappointed Brad just laid there like a Starfish Prince while Stacy had to get on top and did all the work. Brad is still confused and doesn't know why Stacy never called him back.
Sierra has complained for weeks that her boyfriend is never in the mood and when she finally gets him into bed to finally ravage her body, he goes Starfish Prince and just lays there on top of here barely moving and after 5 minutes is finished. He still doesn't know why they broke up.
Sierra has complained for weeks that her boyfriend is never in the mood and when she finally gets him into bed to finally ravage her body, he goes Starfish Prince and just lays there on top of here barely moving and after 5 minutes is finished. He still doesn't know why they broke up.
by DaTrueDefinition October 4, 2019

The act in which a lit cigar is extinguished in a partner's asshole; this act is immediately followed by anal intercourse.
by Big Syxxx September 4, 2011

When the fist of a lucky individual is inserted inside of a female, and then the fingers are expanded to their full length, and the palm is extended as far as possible inside of the woman. This action typically results in immediate female orgasm, and can sometimes be harmful for less experienced women.
Jessica: Joey was starfishing me last night, and I came.
Adriana: Yea, I wish my boyfriend would starfish me!
Adriana: Yea, I wish my boyfriend would starfish me!
by contactonthesmash44 June 4, 2018
