Finger Butler 

A servant to rich and/or lazy to finger themselves.

I'm really horny, but I am too lazy to finger myself. Where is my finger butler?

Finger Butler by Tittletwat March 13, 2015

Butterfingers McGee 

That one player (receiver) in football, more specifically video game football who always drops a pass.

What a mistake going for it on 4th down, especially passing it to Butterfingers McGee, he always drops the pass.

Dammit Butterfingers McGee!! Why the fuck did you drop that pass!

Butterfingers McGee by Dman930 February 18, 2009

butterfingering 

when someone accidentally sticks a finger in their partner's butthole in the heat of the moment.

Did you hear about Lydia? Yeah, Paul's digits slipped and he gave her a good butterfingering.

butterfingering by jessas December 24, 2012

Amish Butterfinger 

When you blow a load in someones asshole, churn it with your finger, and then eat it the shit/cum mixture off your finger.

Dude you want an Amish Butterfinger?

I've been craving an Amish Butterfinger lately...

Amish Butterfinger by AmishButterfinger April 21, 2009

jacksonville butterfinger 

taking a shit in someones mouth while getting a rim job

2 girls 1 cup explicitly shows the proper techniques of the jacksonville butterfinger

jacksonville butterfinger by that guy777 August 11, 2009

butterfingers

When an easy catch is missed because the ball slips through the fingers. Normally used in cricket.

How could you drop that you butterfingers!

butterfingers by Roy Hills February 1, 2004

ButterFinger 

When your wiping your ass with toilet paper, and your finger breaks through and slides across. Creating this brown finger wrapped in toilet paper.

Butterfinger Candy bar, with wrapper pulled down.

ButterFinger by SeanBon45 August 22, 2012