Definitions by AmishButterfinger

Amish Butterfinger 

When you blow a load in someones asshole, churn it with your finger, and then eat it the shit/cum mixture off your finger.

Dude you want an Amish Butterfinger?

I've been craving an Amish Butterfinger lately...

Amish Butterfinger by AmishButterfinger April 21, 2009