Said when a guy who hasn't gotten any in a while strikes out with another girl. Refers to the opening of a jar of peanut butter for the purpose of slathering said peanut butter on one's penis to provide a dog incentive to lick it.
Sexually frustrated man: "I just struck out again! Such a long dry spell..."
Friend: "Might be time to open the peanut butter"
Friend: "Might be time to open the peanut butter"
by Wolf13 October 24, 2014
Get the Open the peanut buttermug. by TheSpartanicaOfAnyHellstromu3e March 26, 2025
Get the Peanut Butter Breath Of Versaillesmug. by LilXangie May 22, 2024
Get the Peanut Butter Monkey Tailmug. the name peanut butter and jelly would make sense as a synonym for explosives training when one compares amateurish home explosives making, I.e. chemical mixing, with amateurish incompetent home cooking, I.e. ingredient mixing.
by Sexydimma December 2, 2014
Get the peanut butter and jellymug. by Safety Pin Queen March 4, 2023
Get the freedom buttermug. Where a woman churns butter in her asshole using her brother's cock, and then shits it on a piece of toasted white or wheat bread and eats it.
by RobsGonnaKillU March 12, 2025
Get the Alabama Buttered Toastmug. by lj2015 January 7, 2016
Get the box buttermug.