The result of a handjob continued after orgasm. So-called because of the churned result from a low-technology method.
"Hey Mitch, you're walking kind of funny."
"Yes, I'm a bit sore after making Amish butter last night."
"Yes, I'm a bit sore after making Amish butter last night."
by DunkinGas June 25, 2022
When you are finished taking a dump, but there isn't anything you can use to wipe nearby, and you waddle cheeks spread to find toilet paper.
Guy 1: What is he doing?
Guy 2: Ha! The Peanut Butter Shuffle! I made sure to take all the paper out of the bathroom.
Guy 1: That's sick dude...
Guy 2: Ha! The Peanut Butter Shuffle! I made sure to take all the paper out of the bathroom.
Guy 1: That's sick dude...
by DangerFinger June 20, 2015
by JazzyBaby313 April 20, 2017
by Jµeíδ May 01, 2004
Brad: hey dude wanna come to my party we’re gonna make some peanut butter and crackers
Nick: peanut butter and crackers?
Brad: yeah we’re gonna spread some peanut butter on Amy and Nicole
Nick: peanut butter and crackers?
Brad: yeah we’re gonna spread some peanut butter on Amy and Nicole
by http.eatallbabies February 05, 2021
by butternoodlegirl January 06, 2021
White Negro: Wouja LIKE some Penis Butter!?!
Buttnigga: Um, sure, yea---
White Negro: I'MMACUMMON YURTITS!!!
Buttnigga: Um, sure, yea---
White Negro: I'MMACUMMON YURTITS!!!
by AutismBlaggleTeam December 06, 2020