A Catholic may tell you they're waiting to have sex until marriage, but she might surprise you with an alternative route. One that involves taking the dirt road home. See "anal"
"I didn't think I was going to get anywhere with Anna, but then she had me give her a Catholic surprise!"
by sexybeast.blue.black December 26, 2022

by TinaWeina December 28, 2009

by Daxhatepage April 1, 2022

by cuntcakes December 15, 2008

Yo dude you know that girl Chelsea from science?
Yeah man what about her?
I gave her a coconut surprise!
Wow what a meatpony!
Yeah man what about her?
I gave her a coconut surprise!
Wow what a meatpony!
by McFetus February 21, 2015

The sexual act of the other partner injecting one of the 5 fingers located on the human hand into the said anus
by thegms June 5, 2024

by Baller7264RN May 27, 2017
