It's only gay when you don't orgasm on the other person's genitals
Steve: You guys had sex? I didn't know you were gay. Larry: Dude, it's not gay, we came on each other's dicks! Steve: Oh, okay then, well when is it gay? Larry: Every other time that doesn't happen.
by TimeToGetCreative April 17, 2018
Get the when is it gay mug.
say this to your friends or in a conversation if you have nothing to say
friend: *walking with you and saying nothing*

me: "when you're gay"
by umm_ello November 7, 2019
Get the when you're gay mug.
It means that she really loves to fuck Cole and that all she does is daydream about it and that she says that she like fucking girls too.
When Sonia calls you gay. You know what that means
by Miss spelling genius February 26, 2022
Get the When Sonia calls you gay mug.