1 definition by TimeToGetCreative

It's only gay when you don't orgasm on the other person's genitals
Steve: You guys had sex? I didn't know you were gay. Larry: Dude, it's not gay, we came on each other's dicks! Steve: Oh, okay then, well when is it gay? Larry: Every other time that doesn't happen.
by TimeToGetCreative April 17, 2018
Get the when is it gay mug.