The 16 Axes of the Pseudoscience Spectrum

The ultimate model, adding the final dimensions of relationship to truth and social function. Building on the 12 Axes, we add: Axis 13: Truth-Seeking-Identity-Protecting (aims at truth vs. aims at protecting group identity). Axis 14: Self-Correcting-Defensive (changes when wrong vs. doubles down). Axis 15: Transparent-Opaque (methods open to scrutiny vs. hidden or secret). Axis 16: Beneficial-Harmful (effects on human welfare). These sixteen axes generate 65,536 potential positions—enough to capture every fringe theory, every pseudoscience, every pathological science. The 16 Axes reveal that pseudoscience isn't a single thing but a family resemblance concept: claims that cluster on the wrong ends of multiple axes. Astrology fails on most axes. Homeopathy fails on most. Climate denial fails on most. But they fail in different patterns, for different reasons, with different consequences. The 16 Axes don't give you a simple pseudoscience detector—they give you a map of the territory, showing why some claims are closer to science and others are farther away, why some are harmless and others deadly, why some are just confused and others are actively deceptive.

The 16 Axes of the Pseudoscience Spectrum "You want a line between science and pseudoscience. The 16 Axes show there is no line—there's a multidimensional space with 65,536 positions. Astrology is far on method, progress, falsifiability, engagement, motivation, explanation, community, authority, evidence, parsimony, consistency, cumulation, identity (it's identity-protecting), defensiveness (doubles down), transparency (methods public but bad), and harm (mostly harmless). Climate denial is far on different axes, with different harms. The 16 Axes don't draw a line—they give you a language for why things are different, even when they're both not science. That's not relativism—that's precision."

by Dumu The Void February 25, 2026