by anonymous May 2, 2023

When a guy asks a girl to cream cheese my bagel he is asking her to put a bagel with cream cheese on his dick and jerk it off while she eats the bagel.
by Licktheclit69 September 28, 2018

When one bagel has more cream cheese/butter than the other, so you have to smush them together to evenly distribute the spread.
by Señor Glumbo February 12, 2025

When a man's penis is too large, so you put a bagel around the base to prevent him from going too deep.
by Donald J. Drumpf August 27, 2021

by Sassafras-tastic January 13, 2024

by SCUBA SKITTLEMAN October 8, 2018
