Said when a guy who hasn't gotten any in a while strikes out with another girl. Refers to the opening of a jar of peanut butter for the purpose of slathering said peanut butter on one's penis to provide a dog incentive to lick it.
Sexually frustrated man: "I just struck out again! Such a long dry spell..."
Friend: "Might be time to open the peanut butter"
Friend: "Might be time to open the peanut butter"
by Wolf13 October 24, 2014
Get the Open the peanut buttermug. When you get two guys and cover them from head to toe with peanut butter, and than procede to vigorously nut all over them and than lick everything off at the end.
by JamesNewton February 4, 2025
Get the Nebraskan Nutter Buttermug. by SuelTameOresuTeMato April 26, 2025
Get the Bread <<<Pan>>>, Butter, And Jalapeñosmug. by TheSpartanicaOfAnyHellstromu3e March 26, 2025
Get the Peanut Butter Breath Of Versaillesmug. When two men cover each others genitalia in peanut butter and jelly, they then rub their shafts together to make a PBJ, they don’t stop until one person cums. Whoever didn’t cum has to lick all of the peanut butter and jelly off of the other person
“Oh boy I really can’t keep doing peanut butter jelqing, Aaron always wins I’m tired of licking up everything”
by Silly bug guy March 5, 2025
Get the Peanut butter jelqingmug. by Blake's nemesis March 27, 2021
Get the soggy toast with buttermug. When someone is so fat that it's hard to penetrate their ass/pussy, they are known as "solid butter" because they're too thick to spread.
Person 1: Ayy man I heard you fucked that fat chick last night. How was she?
Person 2: She was no good. That bitch was a solid butter.
Person 1: You mean she's fat from eating lots of butter?
Person 2: No, she's a solid butter because she's too thick to spread.
Person 2: She was no good. That bitch was a solid butter.
Person 1: You mean she's fat from eating lots of butter?
Person 2: No, she's a solid butter because she's too thick to spread.
by JustEnough June 4, 2023
Get the Solid buttermug.