double-edged butter knife

When something doesn't really work in your favor, but also sort of works against your enemy.

We had to go over to that dickhead John's house. Sean accidentally shit himself, but he was sitting on John's couch when it happened. Classic double-edged butter knife.

by Don Cager February 18, 2021

Foot in the Butter

To fuck up, the art of fucking up

That girl did terrible on her math test, she really had her foot in the butter.

by Foot_in_the_butter_girl June 26, 2018

Peanut butter jelly sandwich

When you fuck your girlfriend in the ass while she really needs to shit and then you cum in her ass and after you pull out it goes all over her ass cheeks making a peanut butter jelly sandwich

Bro last night my girlfriend needed to shit while we were having sex and after I nutted it all came out making a peanut butter jelly sandwich

by JellySandwich July 20, 2025

Jelly Butter

The 'gross' mix of jelly and peanut butter that just doesn't take quite right.

*Sigh* "I hate it when mom buys the jelly butter."

by Earthquaker1987 April 7, 2011

Butter-cupping

When one places a fun-size Reese’s peanut butter cup in her booty, thraxxes that jaunt and then eats the remains out her butt.

“Yeah dawg I was butter-cupping Tracy last night, it was an absolute hoot.”

by momovmnt May 31, 2022

New England Nutter Butter

The act of inserting heavy cream into ones anus and a man churning it with his penis until he ejaculates.

“Me and Chris made some New England Nutter Butter last night!”

by Theodore Foreskin July 5, 2025

Butter

That’s so butter

That’s so butter

by Sir pickle January 2, 2022