Creamy Tuna Surprise 

A creamy tuna surprise occurs when you go down to eat out a chick and you abruptly discover, after removing her panties, that you are about to dine on the sloppy seconds from a dude that just dropped a load in her snatch a few minutes prior.

Chet: Yo braaaa! Where ya been?

Devin: Dude I just took that nasty ho out to the car to eat her snatch.

Chet: Cool braaa! How was it?

Devin: Dude, I didn't eat that box there was a Creamy Tuna Surprise waiting for me. What a nasty ho!

Creamy Tuna Surprise by Eaton Holgoode June 23, 2009

Creamy tropical surprise 

When an individual ejaculates in your pineapple smoothie b4 serving it to you and surprises you when you take a sip

Wow I can’t believe Eugene gave me a creamy tropical surprise

Creamy tropical surprise by Understand me June 16, 2020

Creamy Suprise 

A man ejaculates into his boss's coffee.

P1"Wow dude did you just hear that Ron pulled off the Creamy Suprise?"
P2"Dude no way! His boss must be pissed!"

Creamy Suprise by I got fired doing this June 5, 2020

Pumpernickel Creamsurprise 

When you ejaculate large amounts of cum constantly inside of a yeast-infected-woman's vagina (or anus), to the point where cum rushes out of her vagina (or anus) and you use said cum, mixed with the yeast, to make a creamy, odorous pumpernickel bread that goes under the title "Pumpernickel Creamsurprise"

"My friend John and his girlfriend gave me a loaf of bread called a Pumpernickel Creamsurprise, I can't wait to try it!"

Pumpernickel Creamsurprise by poopybootycoolyfooly June 11, 2025