by Carlover360 November 11, 2020

White Negro: Wouja LIKE some Penis Butter!?!
Buttnigga: Um, sure, yea---
White Negro: I'MMACUMMON YURTITS!!!
Buttnigga: Um, sure, yea---
White Negro: I'MMACUMMON YURTITS!!!
by AutismBlaggleTeam December 6, 2020

by starymars June 17, 2020

a new way of referring to sex, in which the penis butter is a penis and vagelly is vagina and you put the two together and sandwich them between two bodies
by peanutbabe August 26, 2018

This means butter has a very small penis he cant become a daddy he gonna be a virgin for his whole life time.
by IANxSALTY December 12, 2021

Describes the result of condomless (unprotected) sex and ejaculating inside of a vagina, creating a penis butter sandwich, which the perpetrator proceeds to eat after the act.
Man 1: "I ate a penis butter sandwich today."
Man 2: "Was it good?"
Man 1: "No, it needed some fruit."
Man 2: "Was it good?"
Man 1: "No, it needed some fruit."
by MikeHasAMic November 13, 2020

Ok I'll be honest. This phrase doesn't exactly have a meaning yet, but with the power of the internet we can keep on saying it randomly whenever we feel like it and it will eventually catch on and have a meaning of it's own.
It's Penis Butter Jelly Time, Bitch.
It's Penis Butter Jelly Time, Bitch.
by AnonymousPsycho1000 May 13, 2025
