Key West Butt Tickler

Any thick facial hair found on a gay man.

Wow look at that guys Key West Butt Tickler!!

by D Corey September 26, 2007

Key West Butt Tickler

Any big bushy mustache usually worn by homosexual men to attract other homosexual men.

I can tell by your key west butt tickler you enjoy sucking cock.

by Scuzzin420 June 02, 2018

Key West Butt Tickler

Any moustache circa 1978, found on any hawaiian shirt donning television private investigator or general flaming homo. also known as the "Cop Moustache", the "Burt Reynolds", the "Tom Selleck", or the "Magnum PI".

Look at this dude with his easter egg button down and Key West Butt Tickler.

by Major Moleface April 27, 2010