1. To fuck a pencil.
2. To insert a pencil into an improper hole.
3. It can also be used as the same as a piece of shit or an ass hole.
4. To be one, to far, with a pencil.

Pencil fucker has derived from Basher, an American Citizen. It has then been used towards many forms of life.
Ryan is a pencil fucker.
by Basher August 30, 2003
Get the pencil fucker mug.
benji from good charollete... because his pussy is so small and tight that he fucks pencils
by Anonymous July 22, 2003
Get the pencil fucker mug.
The sad, but oh so real, phenomena in which your penis is so small the only enjoyment you will ever receive from it will be from screwing bugs.
Girl 1: Do you think I should date Aaron?

Girl 2: Don't bother; he is a pencil dick bug fucker.
by Shmoobs July 17, 2011
Get the Pencil dick bug fucker mug.