fudge surprise 

Sticking you thumb in your partners butt then putting your thumb in your mouth with the "Fudge" on your thumb

Frank stuck his thumb in bobs ass and then put his thumb in his mouth and got a fudge surprise.

fudge surprise by lDjlSparks April 13, 2005

Hot Fudge Surprise 

After doing a girl doggy style, shit in your hand and in one quick motion SLAM IT DOWN HER F***ING THROAT SCREAMING "HOT FUDGE SURPRISE" AT THE TOP OF YOUR LUNGS

Hey man, last night i gave my girl a hot fudge surprise
"Whats that?"
ITS WHEN I SHIT IN MY HAND AND RAM IT DOWN HER THROAT GOD DAMMIT
"Niccccce"

Hot Fudge Surprise by Jonny Rocketfingers February 25, 2008

Hot Fudge Surprise 

After doing a girl doggy style, shit in your hand and in one quick motion SLAM IT DOWN HER F***ING THROUGHT SCREAMING "HOT FUDGE SURPRISE" AT THE TOP OF YOUR LUNGS

Hey man, last night i gave my girl a hot fudge surprise
"Whats that?"
ITS WHEN I SHIT IN MY HAND AND RAM IT DOWN HER THROAT GOD DAMMIT
"Niccccce"

Hot Fudge Surprise by Jonny Rocketfingers February 25, 2008

Triple fudge brownie surprise 

Where a female sticks some kind of fudge brownie up her vagina and then the man sticks his dick inside until it is fully covered. Then he pulls out and his dick should be black like bret's. Then she sucks all of it off and you can add sprinkles or icing

yo bret why you buying tons of brownies?
Brandon im buying them to give my girl a Triple fudge brownie surprise!

Triple fudge brownie surprise by Brandon the man April 29, 2010