To rapidly press, or "smash", a certain button, very fast. It is most likely used in a quick time event.
Gamer: Man, one time, I was playing BF3, and it asked me to button smash the "X" key, man, after that, the "X" key wasn't the same anymore!
Sexy Guy: I also had the same problem with a girl, last night!
Sexy Guy: I also had the same problem with a girl, last night!
by KOOLGUY® (PT) July 6, 2014

by Op3r4tionCw4l March 30, 2010

When you fuck a girl the first night you meet her and then each subsequent night she regresses to smaller degrees of sexual contact.
Hey, are you still fucking that blonde?
Nah, I got Benjamin Buttoned...she'll only let me spoon her.
Nah, I got Benjamin Buttoned...she'll only let me spoon her.
by MTeasy October 26, 2011

by Mikebeer February 18, 2007

We Benjamin buttoned this relationship, you met my dad first and then hooked up a week before we went on our first date.
by Bonoz June 30, 2018

by Nice guy arc September 13, 2017

"Damn babe, when we fuck tonight I want to suck your love buttons."
"Hey baby, I want you to pleasure my love buttons."
"Hey baby, I want you to pleasure my love buttons."
by HawaiiPDX March 9, 2021
