The result of a handjob continued after orgasm. So-called because of the churned result from a low-technology method.
"Hey Mitch, you're walking kind of funny."
"Yes, I'm a bit sore after making Amish butter last night."
"Yes, I'm a bit sore after making Amish butter last night."
by DunkinGas June 25, 2022
Get the Amish buttermug. When you eat an excessive amount of peanut butter and you're slightly intolerant. You fart and it comes out like hot smooth peanut butter. None of the poots in-between. Just a whole lot of hot smooth air. And you aren't sure if it left peanut butter in your pants.
by Nutterbutterfart March 5, 2020
Get the hot peanut butter fartmug. by Peen77 August 6, 2017
Get the Chug buttermug. Damn !! I was Having Fun with This Girl in Her Doo Doo Maker and my Junk Came Out like a Peanut Butter Corndog
by MichaelAmadeus87 March 22, 2024
Get the Peanut Butter Corndogmug. You know the nickname that you gave that kid whose name "R" in 8th grade. Yeah you know what i'm talkin about.
Yo, Butter, you got the salt?
by xX❌POLYMORPHOUS❌Xx October 28, 2022
Get the Buttermug. Being on the receiving end of anal intercourses, and then allowing your partner to do the same thing within a short period of time!
by Anita Pokin January 30, 2021
Get the Churning buttermug. When having sex with a woman, shortly after climaxing, pulling out and sprinkling sugar and cinnamon on your dick and then having the woman give you oral sex.
by 007Troll69 October 25, 2013
Get the hot buttered churromug.