Top definition
When a girl has sex with a guy for the first time and pulls down his pants to find a very tiny penis (like the size of a pinky finger) which causes her to recoil in disappointment and pity.
Julie hung out with Sean yesterday and he totally pinky-scared her. She said she was sick and went home.
by Julie the Queen November 12, 2007
Get the mug
Get a Pinky-scare mug for your coworker G√ľnter.