Skip to main content

Logical Neutrality Fallacy

The denial that, in practical contexts, logic is not neutral—that power struggles and vested interests operate through logic, and that logic is a space of power just like science and academia. The fallacy lies in insisting that logic floats free of human interests, that logical standards are universal and impartial, when in fact what counts as logical, whose logic counts, and how logic is applied all reflect power relations. Logical Neutrality Fallacy is what happens when privilege becomes invisible—those with logical privilege assume their logic is just logic, not one logic among many backed by institutional power.
"Logic is neutral—it doesn't care who's using it!" That's Logical Neutrality Fallacy—denying that power shapes what counts as logical. But whose logic? Applied by whom? Enforced in what contexts? Western classical logic has power; indigenous logics don't. Logic isn't neutral when one logic gets to define what logic is. Neutrality is a myth; power is real."
Logical Neutrality Fallacy mug front
Get the Logical Neutrality Fallacy mug.
See more merch

Fallacy of Logical Neutrality

The mistaken belief that logic remains neutral in situations of power struggle, paradigm conflict, or hegemonic dispute—that logical rules apply equally to all parties regardless of their position in social, intellectual, or institutional hierarchies. In reality, what counts as "logical" is often determined by those in power, and logical frameworks themselves can be tools of domination. The fallacy lies in pretending that logic floats free of human interests, that it's a pure instrument available equally to all. But when disputing logical paradigms (classical vs. non-classical), logical privileges (who gets to define good reasoning), or logical hegemony (Western logic as universal), neutrality is impossible—logic is part of the struggle, not above it.
"You keep saying 'just be logical' in our debate about indigenous knowledge systems. That's the Fallacy of Logical Neutrality—you're assuming your logic (Western, classical, formal) is neutral, when it's actually one logic among many, and it's the one backed by centuries of colonial power. Logic isn't neutral when one party gets to define what logic is."
well known from south park
rednecks get angrry that future folk took there jobs so they yell
They took ouare jerbs!
Them future folk took ouare jerbs!
jerb by Jimberley Kim April 7, 2005
Word of the Day on May 22, 2026
An Irish phrase meaning shit, derived from ass
(Not to be confused with the literal description of one's buttocks)
"Did you hear the song Aylek$ dropped?"
"Hardly. Her music is absolute cheeks."

"My boyfriend say LaFlame is cheeks."
"Tell your boyfriend I said it's his mixtape that's cheeks."
Cheeks by thecartisan April 26, 2020
Word of the Day on May 21, 2026

sans sheriff 

Lawless use of fonts or typography, with no regard to aesthetics or legibility
I'm putting this CV straight in the bin. Written totally sans sheriff.
sans sheriff by Jamarley July 3, 2019
Word of the Day on May 20, 2026

Breadhead 

Someone who is addicted to obtaining money and building wealth. A money addict and fanatic. Breadheads often work more than one full-time job, and some even participate in illicit activities to "obtain the bread".
A breadhead is like a crackhead, but for money instead of crack.
Breadhead by 🅱️ U S 3 4 8 March 30, 2022
Word of the Day on May 19, 2026

Stink lines

As seen in illustrations or cartoons: Wavy, vertical lines rising above a person, place or thing. Denotes a foul odor.
"You didn't put enough stink lines on your picture of the teacher."
Stink lines by Athene Airheart March 14, 2004
Word of the Day on May 18, 2026