Fallacy of General Privation

A fallacy where someone makes a vague, general accusation of harm or failure—"this system causes suffering," "this idea has negative consequences," "these people have done bad things"—without specifying what harm, to whom, under what conditions, or compared to what alternatives. The accusation is broad enough to be unfalsifiable and vague enough to avoid evidence. General Privation trades on the emotional power of "harm" without the intellectual work of demonstrating it. It's the rhetorical equivalent of "something bad happened somewhere, therefore your point is invalid." The privation is asserted, not demonstrated; generalized, not specified; weaponized, not analyzed.

"Every time I try to discuss economic policy, someone says 'Capitalism causes suffering.' That's the Fallacy of General Privation—vague enough to be unanswerable, broad enough to shut down discussion, and completely useless for actual policy analysis. What suffering? Where? Compared to what? The generality is the point—it's a conversation-ender, not a contribution."

by Dumu The Void February 24, 2026

Flag

Get the Fallacy of General Privation mug.

Tony Plana Is General Zod

by SuelTameOresuTeMato April 25, 2025

Flag

Get the Tony Plana Is General Zod mug.

Tony Plana Are General Zod

by SuelTameOresuTeMato April 25, 2025

Flag

Get the Tony Plana Are General Zod mug.

`~`In`~`General`~`iUn`~`genEral`~`iN`~`generaL`~`

by Angel234IsTheDarkSeraphim April 26, 2025

Flag

Get the `~`In`~`General`~`iUn`~`genEral`~`iN`~`generaL`~` mug.

Pissing in a dollar general

A saying indicating that you feel really powerful or bad ass.
Imagine taking a piss in the aisle of a dollar general, while making relentless eye contact with the cashier - pretty powerful.

I finally gave my misogynistic coworker a piece of my mind today. I feel like I'm pissing in a dollar general.

by Blameitonthealchohol May 12, 2025

Flag