(Also known as Boston Cream Cake and Banana Cream Pie) Boston Cream Pie is a phrase meant for declaring that you have been interrupted while telling a story. The relation between the food and the situation (although weak) is that someone was being interrupted by someone who wanted to talk about pie all the time.
"So anyways, I was went up to her and I-"
"Dude, hold on I need to take this call."
"And then I went back to my room so I could-"
"Would you like a refill of your Sprite sir?"
"Hey, wanna hear something funny?"
"I'm hungry, I'm gonna go grab some food."
"......I guess not..."
These are the situations in which the person interrupted should say:
"Boston Cream Pie"
"Dude, hold on I need to take this call."
"And then I went back to my room so I could-"
"Would you like a refill of your Sprite sir?"
"Hey, wanna hear something funny?"
"I'm hungry, I'm gonna go grab some food."
"......I guess not..."
These are the situations in which the person interrupted should say:
"Boston Cream Pie"
by Scot Taylor January 11, 2009

by Zmxyz December 20, 2020

Don’t. You. Dare. It is a very good dessert from the greatest city on earth and it SHOULD be nothing more or nothing less.
by What’s your handle321 December 13, 2023

by Oinklet August 6, 2022

by Harry Areola March 12, 2022

Them: yo they look like a freak.
Me: no joke. I gave em a Boston Cream Doughnut last week
Them: oh shit
Me: no joke. I gave em a Boston Cream Doughnut last week
Them: oh shit
by OzMuskratt January 2, 2022

"Dude, I totally found a chick that was down for a Boston Cream Doughnut."
"Oh I love Boston Cream Doughnuts. I just had one on my way here!"
"Oh I love Boston Cream Doughnuts. I just had one on my way here!"
by OzMuskratt November 25, 2018
