Law of Privileged Scientific Position

The principle that certain scientific positions are granted unearned authority—privileged not because they're better supported but because they're associated with dominant institutions, funders, or research traditions. The Law of Privileged Scientific Position argues that some research gets funded, published, and cited by default; other research struggles for recognition. This privilege shapes what counts as science, what questions get asked, what answers are accepted. The law calls for examining why certain positions are privileged, who benefits, and what's excluded. It's the foundation of scientific humility, of the recognition that your position's privilege may have nothing to do with its truth.

Example: "Her research, done in community with marginalized populations, was ignored. His research, funded by corporations, was celebrated. The Law of Privileged Scientific Position explained why: his position was privileged, associated with power, with funding, with prestige. Hers wasn't. The difference wasn't evidence; it was privilege. She kept working, hoping that someday privilege would matter less."

by Abzugal February 21, 2026

Theory of Privileged Scientific Position

The systematic elaboration of privileged scientific position as a framework for understanding the politics of knowledge production. The Theory of Privileged Scientific Position argues that scientific authority is not distributed equally—that certain research programs, institutions, and traditions are privileged by their association with dominant power structures. It traces how this privilege operates, how it shapes research agendas, how it excludes alternative knowledge systems. It doesn't claim that privileged science is always wrong; it claims that its privilege should be examined, not assumed. The theory is the foundation of epistemic justice, of the recognition that a fair evaluation of knowledge requires examining not just evidence but the conditions under which it's produced.

Example: "She'd thought science was a meritocracy—best ideas win. The Theory of Privileged Scientific Position showed her otherwise: some ideas started ahead, some started behind. Funding, publication, prestige—all shaped by privilege. She stopped assuming her field's consensus was right because it was consensus and started asking whose interests it served."

by Abzugal February 21, 2026

Theorem of Privileged Scientific Position

A specific proposition within the broader theory of privileged scientific position: that once a scientific position is established as privileged, it tends to reproduce its privilege by defining the terms of what counts as science. The theorem argues that privilege is self-reinforcing: the privileged position sets the standards for funding, publication, and recognition, ensuring that it always appears superior. This is not conspiracy but structure—the rules of science are set by those who already dominate. The Theorem of Privileged Scientific Position explains why marginalized research struggles for recognition, why alternative knowledge systems are dismissed as unscientific.

Example: "Her community's knowledge was dismissed as 'anecdotal,' 'unscientific,' 'not real research.' The Theorem of Privileged Scientific Position explained why: the standards of science were set by institutions that excluded her community. Her knowledge wasn't measured by fair standards; it was measured by standards designed to exclude. She stopped seeking validation and started building her own."

by Abzugal February 21, 2026

External Variables (Scientific Research)

The chaotic, messy, and uncontrollable factors from the real world that invade a controlled experiment and ruin its beautiful, clean data. They are everything the researchers didn't think of, couldn't control for, or actively ignored to make their study publishable. If a lab study shows that people in a quiet room perform better on puzzles, the External Variables are the screaming kids, the pounding hangover, and the constant phone notifications of real life. They are the reason why a drug that works in 100% of carefully selected mice only works in 30% of chaotic, genetically diverse, cheeseburger-eating humans.

External Variables (Scientific Research) "That study saying productivity apps change your life controlled for every Internal Variable. But they didn't account for the External Variables: your battery dying, your boss adding more work, and your cat walking across the keyboard. The lab is a lie; the External Variables are always waiting outside the door."

by Abzugal Nammugal Enkigal February 22, 2026

Theory of Scientific Privilege

The recognition that science, for all its power and validity, occupies a privileged position among ways of knowing that isn't purely meritocratic. Scientific methods produce certain kinds of truth brilliantly, but the privileging of science—the assumption that scientific answers are always the best answers to every question—is a social phenomenon, not a scientific one. This theory examines how scientific privilege shapes policy, marginalizes other knowledge systems, and sometimes overreaches into domains where science has no special authority. It's not anti-science; it's pro-humility.

Theory of Scientific Privilege "Science can tell you the chemistry of this plant, but it can't tell you whether it's sacred. When you act like the chemical answer is the real answer, you're not being scientific—you're exercising Scientific Privilege."

by Abzugal Nammugal Enkigal February 22, 2026