2 definitions by Squash Buckler

When two individuals engage in 69ing. However, instead of a normal 69, each partner is Toe Butting one another. This creates a Toe Butting 69 or Pawtucket Pinkie Toe.
Shelby came over to get help with her homework. I gave her the Pawtucket Pinkie Toe instead.
by Squash Buckler October 17, 2013
Get the Pawtucket Pinkie Toe mug.
Somebody who has a fetish for toes in the butt. This person asks his or her partner to insert their toes into their butt during intercourse.
The girl asked Michael to put his toe in her butt, making her a Toe Butter.
by Squash Buckler October 14, 2013
Get the Toe Butter mug.