A game played by two men utilizing urinals, where one man declares that Butt Pony will be played, and subsequently both men must melee each other to be the first to jam a paper towel tube in between the crotch of the other man's pants whilst they are both urinating. The first man to stop urinating loses.
"Man, gotta pee?"
"Yes."
"Ahhhh...."
"...Hey Steve, I declare Butt Pony!"
"Owww....my colon...."
by Mcb0sse January 23, 2009
Get the Butt Pony mug.
Slang for a person that likes to suck dick and take it up the ass.
Damn, that ho Shanaynay is a cock sucking butt pony.

OR

Look at that faggot. He's a cock sucking butt pony.
by Fenderbender August 7, 2006
Get the cock sucking butt pony mug.