Top definition
A phrase popularised by the Angry Video Game Nerd. Often used in reviews to point out a really shitty feature/scene/piece of shit.

Can also be used to show one's dissatisfaction with something.
Mike: There are aliens in the fourth Indiana Jones.
Jim: What were they thinking?!
by Nitemarish September 06, 2009
Get the mug
Get a What were they thinking? mug for your papa José.