Amish Moon Butter

When you piss into an Amish persons ass and then you churn it with your dick

I want some goddamn Amish Moon Butter.

by mynamebruh May 11, 2023

Amish moon butter

When you piss in their ass and then churn it with your dick.

She had me churn some Amish moon butter in her.

by Goons definitions May 12, 2023

Amish butter

The result of a handjob continued after orgasm. So-called because of the churned result from a low-technology method.

"Hey Mitch, you're walking kind of funny."
"Yes, I'm a bit sore after making Amish butter last night."

by DunkinGas June 25, 2022