Reality Demarcation Problem

The philosophical and practical difficulty of cleanly separating "base reality" from the many conceptual, digital, or subjective layers we live within. It's the problem of pinpointing where the shared, objective physical world ends and where human constructions—like nations, economies, or social media reputations—begin. Since we experience everything through the filter of consciousness and culture, any line we draw is itself a constructed concept. Is a border wall "real"? The concrete is, but the political meaning enforcing it is a constructed layer on top. The problem shows that "reality" isn't a single tier, but a tangled hierarchy of things that have tangible consequences.

Example: "Arguing with a flat-earther, I hit the Reality Demarcation Problem. I cited satellite photos. He said they're CGI by a global cabal. I was appealing to a consensus reality built by science; he was appealing to a counter-reality built by conspiracy. There was no shared foundation to even start the debate. The 'real world' wasn't a fixed stage; it was the prize in the argument."

by AbzuInExile February 1, 2026

Detached from Reality Card

The ultimate dismissal, alleging that someone's foundational premises are so at odds with empirically verifiable facts or consensus reality that productive debate is impossible. This isn't just disagreement; it's the claim that the person has departed from shared reality itself, often into conspiracy, extreme ideology, or solipsism. It declares the argument not merely wrong, but unmoored from the objective world, making rational discourse pointless.

Example: Someone arguing that all world governments are secretly run by lizard people will be met with, "I can't debate someone who's playing the detached from reality card this hard. You're not operating from the same set of facts as the rest of the planet." It draws a boundary between debatable opinion and non-negotiable reality, placing the opponent outside that boundary.

by Abzugal February 3, 2026

Appeal to Reality Fallacy

A more arrogant and absolute version of the "Appeal to Real Life" fallacy. This move claims a monopoly on defining objective "reality" itself, dismissing counter-arguments as not just mistaken but existing in a fantasy realm. It often conflates practical constraints with metaphysical necessity, declaring that one's own view of how things are is the only possible description of reality, making alternative futures or structures "unrealistic" by fiat.

Appeal to Reality Fallacy Example: "Thinking we can achieve world peace is naive. Reality is that humans are inherently tribal and violent. Anyone who believes otherwise is a child." This fallacy elevates a specific philosophical claim about human nature (or current political realities) to the status of an unchangeable cosmic law, using "reality" as a bludgeon to outlaw hope or imagination.

by Abzugal February 3, 2026

Reality Bias

The arrogant epistemological stance that one's own perception or model of the world is an unmediated, objective grasp of "reality," and that anyone who disagrees is either stupid, insane, or evil. It denies the interpretive, constructed, and theory-laden nature of all human understanding. In arguments, it manifests as the definitive declaration, "That's just the way it is," shutting down dialogue about differing experiences or interpretations.

Example: A wealthy CEO states, "If you're poor, it's because you didn't work hard. That's reality." This Reality Bias frames a specific, ideologically loaded belief about meritocracy as an incontrovertible law of nature, dismissing systemic barriers, luck, and inequality as irrelevant fantasies.

by Abzugal Nammugal Enkigal February 4, 2026

Reality Picking

The act of constructing a persuasive but deeply partial version of "reality" by selectively focusing on a subset of facts, experiences, and data points that support a desired narrative, while ignoring a larger, more complex, and often contradictory whole. It is the curation of a believable simulacrum of the world to win an argument, sell a product, or justify a policy.

Reality Picking Example: A news channel builds a nightly broadcast showing only stories of violent crime and urban decay, creating a picked reality of a nation in chaotic, existential collapse. This narrative, built from real but non-representative events, drives ratings and political agendas, while the statistically safer, more mundane reality for most viewers goes unreported.

by Abzugal Nammugal Enkigal February 4, 2026

reality content

User-generated "reality TV" that presents a situation as unscripted and authentic, usually where the videographer just "happens" to be recording and captures some spontaneous event.

"Wasn't that video I sent you crazy!?"
"It would be if it wasn't reality content. There's no way she got the camera out in time to film that."

by rwspeight February 5, 2026