A band who is different from the majority of modern pop-punk bands, and a notable guilty pleasure of many people. They have had a fan base for quite some time, as they have been a band since 2001, as opposed to many pop-punk bands starting around 2005.
Someone: Do you like Forever the Sickest Kids?
Me: No.
Someone: Do you like Mayday Parade?
Me: No.
Someone: The All-American Rejects?
Me: Yes! This is because they're much different from those other pop-punk bands.
Me: No.
Someone: Do you like Mayday Parade?
Me: No.
Someone: The All-American Rejects?
Me: Yes! This is because they're much different from those other pop-punk bands.
by Monstaro May 04, 2009
The All-American Rejects are S.H.I.T.
by non-celebrity inside joke September 05, 2009
by boo ya November 10, 2004
A group of losers who try to come off as hXc with songs like "Swing Swing", in which the lead singer sounds as if he has been castrated.
Preppy Loser: d00d, haV U hUrd thA nU AAA s0nG1!!1!//!/?
Me: No, because the All American Rejects are talentless losers.
Me: No, because the All American Rejects are talentless losers.
by punkgtrst096 March 23, 2005
Gay Fag 6th grader: Did you see the All American Rejects in concert last night? they r0x0rs!!
Wise person: You mean the All American Rejected Retards?
Wise person: You mean the All American Rejected Retards?
by Harry Potter April 10, 2005
Clothes from American Eagle that you don't buy because they don't fit or you don't like them. Based off of the band, "The All-American Rejects"
Vicky- So did you buy that green sweater?
Sandy- No, it ended up being an All-American Eagle Reject.
Stacy- Those clothes are All-American Eagle Rejects, can you go put them back?
Leah- Sure thing.
Sandy- No, it ended up being an All-American Eagle Reject.
Stacy- Those clothes are All-American Eagle Rejects, can you go put them back?
Leah- Sure thing.
by Nancy Drew 5000 September 05, 2009