The act of sticking your finger in your ass and pulling it out to find cum and nutty filled shit on your fingers. Then proceeding to stick them in your partners mouth
My dad gave me a raging new york nutter butter last night. or my grandmothers new york nutter butter taste the best
by DonkeyMcPunch July 1, 2024
Get the New York Nutter Buttermug. When a female puts a bunch of peanut butter in there mouth and a male proceeds to orally fuck her mouth as hard as he can
(M) Hey babe do you wanna do another peanut butter plunge
(F) no my mouth is still sore for the last time
(F) no my mouth is still sore for the last time
by PBPgod69420 July 4, 2023
Get the peanut butter plungemug. The greasy material that is built up over time inside a fur suit that has not been cleaned for a prolonged period of time, as often happens. You can eventually scrape it with a knife to get a swath of butter.
It is made up of sebum, sweat lipids, keratin debris from flaking skin, and bacterial/fungal growth.
It is made up of sebum, sweat lipids, keratin debris from flaking skin, and bacterial/fungal growth.
by anon gamer September 9, 2025
Get the Furry Buttermug. by Ricky the sticky July 7, 2022
Get the Butter Nuttingmug. A person who regularly pursues and engages in sexual activity with butter. faces and is a player about it.
e.g. "Ken was the biggest butter juggler in town, always bragging about his exploits and showing off body-only snaps"
by Dangles December 6, 2018
Get the Butter Jugglermug. by Fringlebop December 7, 2017
Get the butter my spinemug. by SketHunter September 10, 2016
Get the Butter sketchersmug.