Chocolate creme pie

When one cums in another's Anus and then eats it out of their anus

I can't wait to get you home and eat chocolate creme pie

by Repacent March 25, 2023

Pumpkin cream pie

When u carve two holes in a pumpkin and try and touch dicks in the middle and see who can cream first then pull that shit out and make a pumpkin pie using your grandmas recipe then serve it to your family at thanksgiving dinner with love !!! Gobble gobble

Damn I Sure hope Jake invites me to Thanksgiving dinner I heard him and Nathan made a Pumpkin cream pie last night!!!! Boy was Zack pissed

by $horty da Pimp October 19, 2019

Pinkamena-Diane-Pie

Pinkamen-Diane-Pie is A Female Pony From FIM. Her Appearance is a Female Pink Horse with Blue Eyes and Hot Pink Curly Hair. Her Cutie Mark is 3 Balloons, 2 Blue Ones and 1 Yellow. She is apart of the main 6 in FIM and her Element is Laughter.

🎈 🎈 🎈 Pinkamena-Diane-Pie 🎈 🎈 🎈

by OceanGacha July 27, 2021

Oatmeal Cream Pie

When two Latino and one Caucasian have a threesome

Having a oatmeal Cream pie is when a white person and there two Latino gri have a threesome

by Kellz72 August 27, 2022

American Pie challenge

Where you put your dick in a freshly-baked Apple pie like what Jim levenstein did in the 1999 film American Pie.

Matt: "Did you hear what happened to Steve?"

Rob: "No."

Matt: "He did the American Pie Challenge and got hospitalized because of the third-degree burns on his dick."

Rob: "Damn."

by eyeman69 August 28, 2022

party pony pie

A pie in which you stick a plastic horse or pony figurine to celebrate a friend's birthday. Especially used if the figurine is Pinky Pie or is wearing a party hat.

We were too broke for candles this year and the store was out of cakes so we got him a party pony pie instead to celebrate in style!

by Harmonyprincess April 23, 2022

Banana cream pie

A weird yellow pie you get for your bald headed translucent geometry teacher because he rejected the pillow with his face on it.

I gave Mr. D my banana cream pie.

How did it go?

He ate it in front of 17-year-olds and said it was delicious.

by Crusty asshole May 6, 2022