Evidence Picking

A broader and more blatant form of cherry-picking where you selectively choose which pieces of evidence to present, creating a false narrative. It’s the borderer form between simply omitting data and actively fabricating it. You present your "evidence" as a complete picture, but it's actually a carefully curated collection of facts that support your case, with all contradictory facts left on the cutting room floor. It’s the hallmark of a biased documentary or a misleading advertisement.

Example: "The documentary was just evidence picking; they interviewed only happy customers and completely ignored the thousands with complaints."

by Dumu The Void March 11, 2026

Evidence Bias

The unfair weighting or dismissal of evidence based on its source or form, rather than its content. It’s the habit of automatically accepting a statistic from a known source while reflexively dismissing an eyewitness account as "just a story." This bias pre-filters reality, allowing some pieces of information in while barring others at the gate, regardless of their actual merit. It’s the intellectual equivalent of judging a book by its cover and refusing to open it.

Example: "He wouldn't believe my first-hand account of the protest, but immediately trusted a police report that contradicted it. That's Evidence Bias in action."

by Dumu The Void March 11, 2026

Fallacy of Impossible Evidence

The strategic demand for evidence that cannot exist in principle, often used to dismiss claims that are nevertheless well-supported by the evidence that does exist. Unlike demanding more evidence (which can be reasonable), this fallacy demands evidence of a fundamentally different kind—usually the kind that would require time travel, omniscience, or violation of physical law to obtain. "Where were you at 3:17 AM on June 12th, 2008?" when discussing a general pattern of behavior. "Show me a fossil of the exact moment one species became another" when discussing evolution. It weaponizes the impossibility of perfect records against the possibility of any knowledge at all.

Example: "He demanded security footage from a store that burned down in 1985 to prove I shopped there—pure Fallacy of Impossible Evidence, since the evidence he required was literally ashes."

by Dumu The Void March 11, 2026