Top definition
Taking a dump inside of a pillow and sewing it up (without telling your partner), then having sex while pushing your significant others face in the pillow
Person 1: Ever gotten a Scarsdale Suprise?
Person 2: Yeah, I don't wanna talk about it
by Jared Levin January 07, 2006
Get the mug
Get a Scarsdale Suprise mug for your Facebook friend Rihanna.