by Drugs are bad for you February 1, 2017

Store Employee: Peter Pan Peanut Butter Has Been Pulled From The Shelves Due To A "Peter Pan Peanut Butter Alert"
Tourettes Guy: What The Hell Do You Mean A "Peter Pan Peanut Butter Alert"?
Tourettes Guy: What The Hell Do You Mean A "Peter Pan Peanut Butter Alert"?
by McLink99 October 19, 2023

by Canadian doltwad May 25, 2022

Having someone complete the act of masturbation by pulling up and down on the forearm, while the male holds his own penis. This can be done with an infinite number of males. If and when someone ejaculates, it must be done onto a single Nutter Butter. The last person to orgasm must eat this cookie, thus becoming a Brudder for life.
Fraternity initiates; Sam, Dave, Diego, Bill, Steve, and Rod all pair off and begin the Dutch Rudder Nutter Butter Brudder challenge, Bill lost and now must eat the Nutter Butter. Bill is definitely a Brudder.
by Dingus McBerry Johnson July 25, 2021

a stinky smell snatch with peanut butter and jelly slathered all over it for a man or woman to enjoy. NOTE: beware of yeast infections!
dude i had a piece of your girlfriends peanut butter and jelly snatch biscuit last night. it was delicious
by [mtn.dew.me] November 9, 2009

A good ass sandwich that has three pieces of bread with two layers of peanut butter and jelly. Sometimes known to give you deja fat.
Man I ate this good ass sandwich yesterday man.
What the fuck are you talking about.
Double peanut butter and jelly sandwich motha fucka, that shits the shit.
What the fuck are you talking about.
Double peanut butter and jelly sandwich motha fucka, that shits the shit.
by CHODES September 6, 2007

The girl said she likes to give head so I served her up a nice nut butter and jimmy jelly sandwich...needless to say she gobbled it up!
by enonemouswon117 June 27, 2007
