The pieces are puzzling

Synonymous with “the math is mathing”

Meaning that the comment, conversation, or story is making sense or adding up.

Alternatively can be used as “the pieces don’t puzzle” when things do not make sense.

1. “I didn’t know that you had an appointment today.” “I booked it online” “ohhhh the pieces are puzzling”

“I thought he had a girlfriend, but he told me they broke up. Then she sent me a DM about her man! The pieces don’t puzzle.”