Definitions by JewBrew

Bengay Gay 

A sexual endeavor that involves replacing your finest lube with a selection of Bengay (which is supposed to be used as pain relief such as Icy Hot) and continuing with anal sex. She's in for a shocking surprise!

We were having a fine night at her place, until I pulled a Bengay Gay on her and she never talked to me again.

Bengay Gay by JewBrew July 21, 2009